Upon the former defender assumed control as the club's boss in January, he faced scant opportunity to find his feet. A packed match calendar meant a phased integration to his squad was out of the question.
Spanish media highlighted the difficulties he would face, particularly handling a dressing room containing some of soccer's biggest personalities.
But forging strong relationships with the footballers did not seem to faze the ex- Liverpool full-back.
"It's not something that troubles me greatly," Arbeloa stated at his first media appearance.
60 days on, he states those rapports are strengthening and the outcomes on the field are coming as a result.
Forging Bonds
In March, Arbeloa guided his side to victories against sides coached by top-tier managers: the Portuguese manager's Benfica, the Catalan's City and Diego Simeone's Atletico.
Los Merengues are still four points behind the Spanish league leaders Barcelona, with a crucial upcoming Clasico in May, while their European journey rolls on with a last-eight encounter against the German giants.
The team's form are improving and the chemistry between the coach and squad are developing.
"I'm getting to understand the individuals better and better," said Arbeloa following Real Madrid's 3-2 victory against rivals Atletico Madrid recently.
"I arrived at a juncture when I almost had insufficient time to observe the squad, to see where they were at ease, and to witness how they interacted with one another."
He admitted the circumstances of his hiring created unique obstacles.
"For me, it's difficult to arrive in the middle of the campaign and observe how the team functions, and that's what has changed over these two months," he continued.
"At present I understand my charges as individuals and footballers, where I can extract the optimal output from them, and where I can tweak things."
Acclaim for Vinicius Jr
A key individual flourishing under Arbeloa is the Brazilian winger.
He has started 16 of Arbeloa's 17 matches in charge, with his output also rising markedly - he has found the back of the net 11 goals under Arbeloa, versus registering just six in 27 appearances under his predecessor.
Arbeloa has focused on bolstering the attacker's confidence, urging him to express himself and be creative rather than limiting him in terms of tactics.
"I am fortunate to have Vini, he's adored by the entire fanbase. We want to see the Vini who has fun on the pitch, who laughs, who dances… that is the player I want to see," he declared in his first news conference as manager.
That approach differs from rumors of tension under Alonso, with Vinicius muttering "I'm going to quit this team" after being substituted in last match against Barcelona.
Arbeloa has openly stood up for him, emphasizing he is completely supported by the coaching staff and the dressing room.
"He is among the deadliest players, if not the deadliest, in the world and he epitomizes what a Real Madrid star is," added the manager.
Vinicius put discussions about his long-term prospects on hold last summer but, recently, he affirmed his loyalty clear.
"I'm only thinking about this club and staying there for a long time," he informed the press before Brazil's friendly match with France.
Valverde Finds His Best Form Again
Fede Valverde's form has also improved dramatically since Arbeloa arrived.
Under Alonso, he registered three strikes and seven assists from 31 games.
Ever since the manager's arrival, he has been named in the starting eleven for all 17 of his matches in charge, finding the net seven times and registering five assists.
A major reason has been a change in role to his natural place in midfield.
During the former coach's time in charge, the player at times found it hard to secure a starting spot in his preferred position, being positioned in unusual roles such as right-back.
Although the choice was partly driven by fitness issues to other players, his frustration was clear. "I wasn't born to be a defender," he remarked.
But now, restored to his favored role, Valverde is thriving.
He has bagged six strikes in just a month, including a three-goal haul against Manchester City and a crucial goal in a 3–2 win over Atletico Madrid.
Youth Integration, More Potential?
Arbeloa's prior role as boss of the club's B team has made integrating young players into the senior side feel natural, so it was logical to expect him to give emerging talent opportunities.
This occurred more notably when the team faced Elche earlier this month and Arbeloa provided opportunities to six youth team players.
One player, in especial, has swiftly made a name for himself as one of the manager's most promising disciples.
At just 18 years and 226 days, he made history as the youngest footballer in the team's history to start twice in the Champions League knockout stages, breaking a previous milestone by 10 days.
Questioned what it meant to see five homegrown players on the field, Arbeloa couldn't hide his delight.
"I believe I can be content after a evening like this one," he remarked.
"I was just talking to two of them, who were the initial youngsters I coached when they were 13 or 14, and to be able to give them the opportunity to perform at the Santiago Bernabeu is a dream come true for me."
While Arbeloa might be familiar with the youth team members, he admits injuries have restricted his exposure